View profile

What happens when you are under constant surveillance?

Those in support of constant and invasive surveillance by the state ask: "what do you have to hide?"
August 27 · Issue #59 · View online
iAfrikan Daily Brief
Those in support of constant and invasive surveillance by the state ask: “what do you have to hide?” when one opposes surveillance. However, they don’t understand the second and third order effects of constant surveillance. - Tefo Mohapi

Have you ever been conscious that you are under constant surveillance and somebody is literally watching everything you do?
Well, I remember growing up in Pretoria in the late 1980s and early 1990s, it was a transitionary period for South Africa and many of the racially based movement restrictions were starting to be relaxed. Black people could now live in “the suburbs” and roam around town without a curfew or any restrictions.
However, as a teenager, I remember vividly how when walking into retail stores and bookstores the shop attendants would follow me around at every single turn inside the shop and stand uncomfortably close for my liking, I would even feel guilty that I’d need to blow my nose while inside the store given the constant surveillance.
Uganda's Police Force is working with China's Huawei Technologies to install CCTV cameras equipped with facial recognition capabilities. Opposition political parties have raised concerns that this will be used to track and target them. This is one of the surveillance cameras in Kampala.
I was reminded of that period in time when I read that China’s Huawei Technologies is working with Uganda’s Police Force to install CCTV facial recognition cameras. According to the police, the cameras will help stop violent crime.
Now, Uganda’s opposition political party leaders have come out to oppose the installation of the AI-powered cameras saying that they are being installed to target and harass them and their followers. Given Ugandan authorities history on clamping down on dissent online and in real-life, I tend to agree with them. However, there are other second order effects of being constantly under surveillance.
One of the first things that happens to most people when they know they are constantly being watched for any bad behaviour is that they develop increased anxiety and stress. You don’t want to f*** up because of the potential consequences. This, according to some researchers, is as a result of feeling a loss of privacy in ones life.
As a result, as you can imagine, you become overly conforming to whatever the rules irrespective if they are legal or sensible. The idea that there is a constant camera watching your every move, although not a direct order, many people end up feeling the need to conform to whatever the state (reasonable or not) expects of them. A third order effect of this is that it potentially (to the benefit of the state) takes away people’s agency and their inclination to protest or disagree.
Does surveillance reduce crime? Possibly.
However, in my humble opinion, it does more damage to the fabric of society than it benefits it. In Uganda’s case, this might be something the state wants given that in a couple of years there will be elections.
On the other hand of all this, you get the bias that is typically associated with algorithms. Like the City of Johannesburg which claims to have intelligent cameras that can “detect criminal behaviour.” But that’s a topic for another day.
City of Joburg
The City’s intelligence operations center will have intelligent public cameras that can detect criminal behavior and dispatch response teams. Several arrests have already been thanks to the IOC #JoburgWorks^TK
9:48 AM - 30 Jun 2019
News websites have been blocked in Egypt
Uganda and Rwanda agree to unblock news websites
Nigeria is not a major global cybercrime player
Google introduces new policies for personal loan apps
Did you enjoy this issue?
If you don't want these updates anymore, please unsubscribe here
If you were forwarded this newsletter and you like it, you can subscribe here
Powered by Revue